This is a truly off topic post, but there’s some thoughtful people on here that I wouldn’t mind hearing from. One of the trends that I’ve noticed - and maybe it’s always been this way and I haven’t been paying attention - is that increasingly “fans” are people who are constantly upset by the movies, games, comic books etc. that they are supposed to be fans of. I was always under the impression that a prerequisite for being a fan was that you had to like something.
There was a Zombieland TV series a year or two ago and it got canned quickly, with the developers blaming the “fans” of the movie for being hyper critical and slagging the series. They (the writers - who were also the writers of the movie) were pretty upset, and I can certainly understand it. But it seems like part of a larger trend to me. I know comic book nerds are famously angry about everything, but it’s pretty clear that it’s only comic book fans that hate comic book movies. And, although much can be said about the Star Wars prequels, it’s always “Star Wars fans” that seem to hate them the most…
I bring this up for obvious reasons. We have a lot of people disappointed about the 3 stage announcement (that I don’t want to go into here - so please don’t derail the thread) who are not just unhappy. They are slagging the ■■■■ out of the game, the developers, the funders and the future of the game. Claiming that they are fans and have been betrayed.
What’s the point of this ramble? I think we can all agree that you don’t have to unconditionally love everything about a franchise to call yourself a fan. I’m a Star Wars fan and I’m not super fond of the prequels. But how much hate can you drop on something and still be a fan? Where do we draw the line? If you are actively working against the success of something, can you really call yourself a fan?
One of the things that I think these incidents have in common is the illusion that “fans” have that they are owners of a franchise. How many Star Wars fans hate George Lucas? Why do comic book fans think that they, rather than the writers who actually write the books, should get to say what should happen to those characters? Somehow, many of these people have the (mistaken, in my opinion) idea that they have just as much invested in these characters/movies/games as the people making them. That their contribution, just by being a fan, is equal to or greater than the people actually creating them, and therefore they should get an equal say.
Maybe this bothers only me, but I thought I would throw it out there.